866 OTP Law1 (Toll Free)
866-687-5291
They aren't as exciting as you might hope for.  The trial is called a hearing. It may be in a court room but is often in a meeting room at a community college or libarary. The judge is called a deputy commissioner and he or she will be wearing a suit rather than a black robe. The hearing is technically open to the public although it is pretty rare for anyone to be watching one.   At the beginning of the hearing the deputy commissioner will review a Pre-Trial Agreement where the lawyers have agreed to certain facts not in dispute, agreed on what the issues to be decided by the deputy commissioner will be, and agreed on what may come into evidence. The deputy commissioner will then ask whichever side requested the hearing to proceed.  Whichever side is going first will call witnesses who will be sworn in on a Bible (you may affirm to tell the truth if you prefer). Whoever calls the witness asks questions first in what is called a direct examination. Then the other attorney has a cross-examination. There may be brief follow-up questions as a redirect and recross but this is pretty limited. After the first side is done with witnesses they rest their case.  The defending side may then put on evidence in a similar manner.  At the end of the hearing the deputy commissioner will usually give the lawyers 60 days to go to your doctors' offices and take testimony, known as depositions, from the doctors. The lawyers then have 30 days to submit written arguments, known as contentions or proposed opinion and awards, to the deputy commissioner. The deputy commissioner will take two to four months to issue a decision called an opinion and award.  The losing party has 15 days to appeal the case to the Full Commission. If that happens the entire question and answering from the hearing is reduced to a written transcript. Once the transcript is prepared the attorneys prepare written arguments as to why the deputy commissioner got it right or wrong. The lawyers then appear before a panel of three commissioners in Raleigh and give a 20-minute presentation about your side of the case. The Full Commission then issues its own opinion and award in another two to four months.  The losing party can theoretically take the case to the North Carolina Court of Appeals, however this is not often done. The Court of Appeals will not review findings of fact -- that is to say if the Full Commission decides that you have green hair, even if there is some evidence that you may have blue hair, the Court of Appeals will not second guess what the Full Commission has found as fact. The Court of Appeals is limited to assessing whether or no the Full Commission properly applied North Carolina law to those facts.

Practice Areas

Firm News

view all

Library

Workers' Compensation

view all

Testimonials

"I'm so thankful that I found your firm when I did an internet search."

"Your firm works hard for all your clients -- even small ones like me."

"I heard your ad on TV.  John Landry and Lindsay are the greatest!"

"You made me feel like I was your only client."

"Thank you!  I will never forget all that you did for me."

"I wanted expert legal advice and I certainly got it!"

"Oxner Thomas Permar has a well-known reputation for fighting fair and winning cases.  We were well-prepared by our attorney, and we were given thorough guidance and options."

"I think of everyone involved on my case at OTP as friends.  You all always had a warm greeting  and a smile for me and you took a big interest in my case."

"Without my attorney's help, I would have been hung out to dry.  He looked out for me!"

"I could not be more pleased with the outcome of my case!  Amy Berry and Amy Gallimore are great communicators.  They are super friendly and professional."

more

Information for injured workers in North Carolina

 


Q: What is a workers' compensation trial like?

A: They aren't as exciting as you might hope for.

The trial is called a hearing. It may be in a court room but is often in a meeting room at a community college or libarary. The judge is called a deputy commissioner and he or she will be wearing a suit rather than a black robe. The hearing is technically open to the public although it is pretty rare for anyone to be watching one.

At the beginning of the hearing the deputy commissioner will review a Pre-Trial Agreement where the lawyers have agreed to certain facts not in dispute, agreed on what the issues to be decided by the deputy commissioner will be, and agreed on what may come into evidence. The deputy commissioner will then ask whichever side requested the hearing to proceed.

Whichever side is going first will call witnesses who will be sworn in on a Bible (you may affirm to tell the truth if you prefer). Whoever calls the witness asks questions first in what is called a direct examination. Then the other attorney has a cross-examination. There may be brief follow-up questions as a redirect and recross but this is pretty limited. After the first side is done with witnesses they "rest their case."

The defending side may then put on evidence in a similar manner.

At the end of the hearing the deputy commissioner will usually give the lawyers 60 days to go to your doctors' offices and take testimony, known as depositions, from the doctors. The lawyers then have 30 days to submit written arguments, known as contentions or proposed opinion and awards, to the deputy commissioner. The deputy commissioner will take two to four months to issue a decision called an opinion and award.

The losing party has 15 days to appeal the case to the Full Commission. If that happens the entire question and answering from the hearing is reduced to a written transcript. Once the transcript is prepared the attorneys prepare written arguments as to why the deputy commissioner got it right or wrong. The lawyers then appear before a panel of three commissioners in Raleigh and give a 20-minute presentation about your side of the case. The Full Commission then issues its own opinion and award in another two to four months.

The losing party can theoretically take the case to the North Carolina Court of Appeals, however this is not often done. The Court of Appeals will not review findings of fact -- that is to say if the Full Commission decides that you have green hair, even if there is some evidence that you may have blue hair, the Court of Appeals will not second guess what the Full Commission has found as fact. The Court of Appeals is limited to assessing whether or no the Full Commission properly applied North Carolina law to those facts.


Bookmark and Share

Free Answers

Offices

OTP - Greensboro
1155 Revolution Mill Drive,
Studio 4
Greensboro, NC 27405
Phone: 336-274-4494
Fax: 336-271-6769
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

OTP - Winston-Salem
110 Oakwood Drive, Suite 420
Winston-Salem, NC 27103
Phone: 336-274-4494
Fax: 336-631-5225
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

OTP - Burlington
409 Alamance Road, Suite C
Burlington, NC 27215
Phone: 336-226-5925
Fax: 336-226-4492
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

OTP - Asheboro
904 South Cox Street
Asheboro, NC 27203
Phone: 336-633-4496
Fax: 336-633-3394
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

OTP - Raleigh
3700 Glenwood Avenue, Suite 350
Raleigh, NC 27612
Phone: 919-573-5241
Fax: 919-785-2239
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

OTP - Fayetteville
4200 Morganton Road, Suite 200-11
Fayetteville, NC 28314
Phone: 910-764-3363
Fax: 910-764-3364
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

OTP - Charlotte
550 S. Caldwell Street, Suite 1800,
Charlotte, NC 28202
Phone: 704-547-1617
Fax: 704-574-1819
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

OTP - Hickory
101 Government Avenue SW
Hickory, NC 28601
Phone: 828-322-1271
Fax: 828-322-1643
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

OTP - Wilmington
1213 Culbreth Drive,
Wilmington, NC 28405
Phone: 910-509-7274
Toll Free: 1-866-OTP-Law1

FAQs

Workers' Compensation

What's the definition of Average Weekly Wage?

What's medical compensation?

more

Case Studies

Workers' Compensation

What Can Go Wrong with a Return to Light Duty Work.

How a Functional Capacities Evaluation Can Wreck a Claim.

An Example of a Workers' Comp Adjuster Manipulating the Recorded Statement.

more